Case in Notre Dame Football QB…
South Bend, IN — Questions are swirling around Notre Dame’s quarterback situation as the team prepares for what could be one of the most critical stretches of its season. The “case in Notre Dame football QB” room has become one of the most discussed topics in college football circles, with fans and analysts closely watching every move from the Fighting Irish coaching staff.
Entering the 2025 season, Notre Dame had high hopes pinned on junior quarterback Tyler Mitchell, who started strong last year before an injury sidelined him midway through the season. In his absence, freshman standout Jordan Reaves impressed with his composure and athleticism, giving the coaching staff a difficult decision heading into the summer.
Now, head coach Marcus Freeman finds himself at the center of a quarterback dilemma that is as much about performance as it is about leadership and team chemistry. “It’s not just about who throws the best ball,” Freeman told reporters this week. “It’s about who commands the huddle, who leads in the locker room, and who helps us win football games in November.”
Mitchell has experience and a deeper understanding of the playbook, something offensive coordinator Tommy Rees values greatly. However, Reaves brings a dual-threat capability that Notre Dame hasn’t consistently had at the position in years. His ability to extend plays and create opportunities outside the pocket adds a dynamic element to the Irish offense.
Sources close to the program say the competition remains open, and both quarterbacks have been splitting first-team reps during practice. While Mitchell has recovered fully from his shoulder injury, he faces increased pressure from Reaves, who has continued to impress teammates with his quick decision-making and athleticism.
Adding complexity to the quarterback case is the emergence of a third option: sophomore Drew Holtz, a former four-star recruit who has reportedly made significant strides during spring training. While not as flashy as Reaves or as experienced as Mitchell, Holtz offers a balanced skill set and strong leadership qualities.
With the season opener against Texas looming in late August, the coaching staff is expected to make a decision by early July to allow the offense to gel. Still, Freeman insists that performance in camp—not past accomplishments—will determine the starter.
“This isn’t about seniority,” Freeman said. “It’s about who gives us the best chance to win, plain and simple.”
For Irish fans, the quarterback case has added an extra layer of intrigue to the offseason. While the team boasts one of the most talented rosters in recent memory, the decision under center could make or break Notre Dame’s College Football Playoff hopes.
As training camp continues, the spotlight remains firmly on the quarterback room. Whether it’s Mitchell’s experience, Reaves’s electric playmaking, or Holtz’s steady progress, the Irish will need the right man to lead them forward.
The case in Notre Dame football QB is far from settled—and all eyes will be on South Bend to see how it plays out.
