Despite another strong performance from young guns Hugo Savala and Sandon Smith in the Sydney Roosters’ 42-8 win over the Cowboys on Sunday, Manly Warringah Sea Eagles captain Daly Cherry-Evans is still widely expected to sign for the club.
Should the Roosters chase the veteran halfback, or back their rising stars to lead the way?
Despite another resounding victory spearheaded by their rising stars, the Sydney Roosters face a defining question: Should they pursue experienced playmaker Daly Cherry-Evans or place their faith in the impressive form of their young halves?
On Sunday, the Roosters continued their NRL resurgence with a commanding 42-8 triumph over the North Queensland Cowboys. Leading the charge were young halves Hugo Savala and Sandon Smith, both of whom turned in mature, composed performances that belied their limited first-grade experience. Their chemistry was evident from the opening whistle, orchestrating attacking plays with flair and precision, while also maintaining defensive discipline.
But even in the glow of this emphatic win, speculation around Manly Sea Eagles captain Daly Cherry-Evans joining the Roosters continues to build. The veteran halfback, who has been the cornerstone of Manly’s spine for over a decade, is reportedly considering a switch to the Roosters in the twilight of his career—a move that could inject further leadership and experience into the squad.
The dilemma now facing the Roosters’ management is whether to disrupt the momentum of their promising young halves in favor of the proven class and leadership of Cherry-Evans. At 35, the Queensland Origin and Australian representative remains among the most strategic minds in the game. His composure under pressure and ability to guide a team through tough contests is unmatched. For a club like the Roosters—who are perennially chasing premierships—bringing in a seasoned campaigner like Cherry-Evans may seem like a logical step.
However, critics argue that such a move could stunt the development of the very players who are shaping up to be the Roosters’ future. Savala, in particular, has displayed a maturity beyond his years. His kicking game and decision-making have improved significantly, while Smith’s dynamism and vision provide the perfect balance. Many supporters believe it’s time to fully invest in the youth project, allowing the next generation to lead with confidence rather than playing second fiddle to a veteran.
Trent Robinson, the Roosters’ head coach, faces a tough balancing act. With finals footy fast approaching, consistency in the spine is vital. Cherry-Evans could offer the steadiness needed in high-pressure situations, but it would also mean reshuffling a formula that is currently delivering strong results.
The Roosters have a history of integrating stars into their roster while maintaining youth development—James Tedesco, Luke Keary, and Jared Waerea-Hargreaves all joined as experienced players and played vital roles alongside emerging talents. Whether Cherry-Evans becomes the next to don the Tricolours jersey remains to be seen, but one thing is clear: the Roosters are in a strong position, with options aplenty.
For now, fans can enjoy watching the youth thrive, even as the shadow of a marquee signing looms large. The decision may well define the Roosters’ direction for years to come.
